Thomas Tuchel is expected to avoid the backlash faced by Sven-Goran Eriksson as the first foreign coach of the England national team. A protester outside FA headquarters in London in 2000 held a banner reading “FA, hang your heads in shame. No surrender.” Eriksson’s appointment was met with criticism from figures like Gordon Taylor and John Barnwell. Jeff Powell of the Daily Mail famously criticized the decision, describing it as selling out to a nation of skiers and hammer-throwers.
Eriksson, reflecting on his time with England, joked, “England: you can’t say no.” Despite several disappointments and tabloid scrutiny, Eriksson never regretted taking on the role. Fabio Capello, the second foreign coach of England, did not express the same sentiment.
The impending appointment of Tuchel is reminiscent of a bygone era. The FA had previously emphasized the importance of grooming homegrown coaches, especially with the establishment of St George’s Park. However, the expected surge in local coaching talent did not materialize as anticipated.
The lack of success of English managers in European competitions highlighted the need for a shift in strategy. The preference for a homegrown candidate still existed, but the appointment of Tuchel signifies a departure from that ideal.
The FA’s decision to opt for Tuchel was influenced by his successful coaching stints at various top clubs. While English coaches like Howe and Potter have achieved commendable feats, they have not reached the pinnacle of the game. Tuchel’s track record of winning major trophies sets him apart from local candidates.
The international game poses unique challenges that may require a different skill set in a manager. Recent tournament performances have emphasized the need for a coach with a winning mentality and experience at the highest level.
The backlash against an overseas coach leading the England team reflects a sentiment that the national side should be managed by a local tactician. While the influence of foreign coaches has been positive for English football, there is a growing call for a return to English leadership on the international stage.
As Tuchel takes on the mantle of England manager, he faces the task of living up to the standards set by his predecessor, Southgate. With the unpredictability of international football, success is not guaranteed, regardless of the coach’s nationality.
(Top photo: Sven Hoppe/picture alliance via Getty Images; design: Meech Robinson)