The NFL’s new kickoff rules aim to bring back one of the most thrilling plays in the game while reducing the risk of injuries from high-speed collisions. The strategy is to adopt a setup similar to the XFL, which could offer more opportunities for return men.
However, there is a potential drawback. The NFL’s decision to allow the coverage unit to start their pursuit when the ball hits the ground or when the returner touches it, like in the XFL, may limit the options for return teams. In the XFL, this led to confusion and mistimed starts by the coverage team, disrupting the flow of the game.
According to one NFL special teams coach, the new rules could encourage teams to use unconventional and erratic kicks to exploit the system. This could result in chaotic situations on the field.
GO DEEPER
Making sense of NFL’s new kickoff rule and what it means for next season
The changes in kickoff rules were intended to make the play more exciting. However, if teams consistently kick the ball on the ground to disrupt the play, the league may revisit this rule. Teams have realized that when the ball hits the ground, it becomes challenging to block opponents.
To adapt to the new rules, some teams like the Kansas City Chiefs are exploring unconventional options, such as using former rugby players as kickers. These kicks do not need to be perfect, and a well-placed bad kick can create the illusion of hangtime.
(Drew Jordan / The Athletic)
Additionally, kickers are now more involved in tackles due to the rule changes. This shift has forced special teams coordinators to rethink their strategies to protect their valuable kickers.
With the potential for more creativity in return teams under the new rules, the addition of a second returner and higher-quality players could lead to innovative plays. Yet, the conservative nature of special teams coaches and the fear of errors may limit the willingness to experiment with new tactics.
Despite the uncertainties surrounding the new rules, coaches are optimistic and are continually exploring strategies during practices and training camps. While some teams may play it safe, others are determined to find an edge.
Teams are aware of the strategic opportunities presented by the new rules and are working to capitalize on them. The learning process will continue as teams adapt to the changes.
Free, daily NFL updates direct to your inbox. Sign up
Free, daily NFL updates direct to your inbox. Sign up
Buy
The Chiefs’ innovative approach under head coach Andy Reid, including experimenting with rugby players, reflects a willingness to think outside the box. The potential for unconventional tactics in kickoff returns has sparked discussions among coaches and analysts.
The new kickoff format will require a different type of returner—one who can handle the physicality of the game and execute strategic plays. With the opportunity for more running back-style returners and the addition of a second returner, teams are exploring new possibilities in kickoff returns.
Exploring ideas from rugby, such as switch plays, could offer creative solutions for kickoff returns. Teams are experimenting with various strategies to maximize the space and opportunities provided by the new kickoff format.
Ultimately, teams that adapt quickly and efficiently to the new rules and develop innovative strategies will have a competitive advantage. The learning process will continue throughout the season as teams refine their approaches.
(Top illustration: Dan Goldfarb / The Athletic; photos: Dan Mullan / The RFU Collection and Justin Tafoya / Getty Images)