A high-ranking officer in the Philippine Navy has refuted claims of striking a new agreement with the Chinese government to ease tensions over a disputed shoal in the South China Sea. This officer, Vice Adm. Alberto Carlos, broke his silence for the first time since stepping down from his position in early May.
Speaking at a Senate Committee hearing investigating the alleged recording of a phone call between Carlos and a Chinese military attaché, Carlos acknowledged the conversation but denied making any binding agreements that would redefine foreign policy between the two countries.
Carlos emphasized that he did not engage in any secret deals that would compromise the country’s interests, urging unity against false narratives. The recorded conversation released by the Chinese embassy purportedly revealed an informal agreement on managing tensions at Second Thomas Shoal.
During the hearing, Carlos explained that the call was brief and informal, focusing on ways to reduce tensions following incidents at the atoll in the Spratly Islands. He distanced himself from discussions of a “new model” or “common understanding,” as claimed by Chinese officials.
The leaked phone call, which ignited a legal debate on wiretapping violations, prompted calls for the expulsion of Chinese diplomats over alleged disinformation tactics. Despite Beijing’s accusations of violating agreements, both Carlos and the Philippine government have denied these claims.
The lack of trust between the Philippines and China, exemplified by the leaked call, indicates a deteriorating relationship with no immediate resolution in sight. As tensions continue to escalate, prospects for reconciliation appear bleak.